Shimla: The Himachal Pradesh High Court has sought a detailed response from the state government over construction activity near the historic Ellerslie building in Chhota Shimla, which houses the state secretariat. The controversy, involving construction linked to the proposed new Chief Minister’s Office, has raised questions over heritage conservation norms, mandatory setbacks and the approvals granted for the project.
The court registered a public interest litigation after taking cognisance of a complaint filed by Captain Atul Sharma, who alleged that new concrete structures had come up in close proximity to the heritage building, affecting its historic character and architectural setting. According to the complaint, parts of the new construction are visibly rising above the existing structure, altering the visual profile of the historic complex.
Sharma had sought information under the Right to Information Act regarding permissions granted for the construction, along with records of meetings of the Heritage Cabinet Sub-Committee. An order passed by the High Court on August 17, 2026, reportedly noted that documents relating to the approvals had been provided. However, the petitioner contended that these records indicated non-compliance with mandatory setback requirements.
The petitioner has sought an independent investigation into the entire construction process, including the legality of the permissions granted. He has proposed the constitution of an expert committee comprising heritage conservation specialists, engineers and senior administrative officials to inspect the site and submit its findings within a stipulated timeframe.
The complaint also seeks accountability of officials who allegedly approved construction in violation of applicable norms or failed to intervene despite possible violations. It has called for departmental and legal action against those found responsible.
During the hearing on August 17, the High Court appointed senior advocate Devyani Sharma to assist the court as amicus curiae. On September 21, the court directed the state government to submit a detailed response along with an affidavit, granting it three weeks to do so.
At the November 5 hearing, the government informed the court that its reply had been filed. However, the document was not available on the judicial record. The court directed the state to rectify any deficiencies and ensure that the response was placed on record before the next hearing.
The matter is now listed for December 22, 2026.
The controversy puts the spotlight on the process through which construction permissions were granted in the vicinity of one of Shimla’s significant historic government buildings. At the centre of the dispute are questions about whether heritage considerations and mandatory building regulations were adequately examined before the construction was allowed to proceed.
The government will now have to explain the statutory basis for the approvals and address the allegations concerning setback violations. The court proceedings are expected to examine not only the permissions granted but also the responsibility of the authorities concerned in ensuring compliance with construction and heritage conservation requirements.


