3,092 uterus removal surgeries in three hospitals; two beneficiary cards raise questions over healthcare delivery, scheme monitoring and transparency
Shimla
The Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu government’s claims of strengthening healthcare in Himachal Pradesh face questions on two fronts, one the scale of major surgical procedures in government hospitals and the implementation of its health welfare schemes.
Information obtained under the Right to Information (RTI) Act, along with two HIMCARE beneficiary cards, brings into focus the larger issue of transparency, monitoring and accountability in the state’s public healthcare system.
The RTI disclosures reveal that 3,092 hysterectomy procedures, involving the surgical removal of the uterus, were performed at three major government medical institutions between 2019 and 2022. The figures cover Indira Gandhi Medical College (IGMC), Shimla, Kamla Nehru State Hospital (KNH) and Dr Rajendra Prasad Government Medical College, Tanda.
The highest number was reported by KNH, where 2,633 procedures were performed. Tanda Medical College recorded 448, while IGMC Shimla reported 11.
The year-wise figures from KNH stood at 814 in 2019, 429 in 2020, 600 in 2021 and 779 in 2022. At Tanda, 156 procedures were performed in 2019, 57 in 2020, 80 in 2021 and 155 in 2022.
The figures has raised an important question that does the state have an effective mechanism to review the medical justification, clinical outcomes and hospital-wise variations in such major surgical procedures?
Although the data predates the present Sukhu government and does not establish any irregularity, the current administration must explain what steps have been taken to strengthen clinical audits and ensure transparency in government hospitals.
HIMCARE cards reveal different premium entries
The two HIMCARE beneficiary cards provide another perspective on the state’s healthcare delivery system.
One card, registered on February 21, 2023, under the senior citizens above 70 years category, records a premium amount of zero. The other card lists a 71-year-old male as the head of the family and a 69-year-old woman as a dependent.
The second card, registered on April 26, 2023, under the General category, records a premium payment of ₹1,000. The family includes four members, including a 66-year-old father, a woman and a minor child.
Both cards carry policy validity dates in 2026. The records therefore raise questions about the basis of premium assessment, eligibility criteria and the transparency of the scheme’s registration process.
The different premium entries alone do not establish any discrimination or irregularity, as the beneficiaries belong to different recorded categories. However, the government needs to ensure that eligibility conditions, premium requirements and benefits are clearly communicated to every household.
Healthcare promises versus ground-level accountability
Himachal Pradesh has repeatedly projected public healthcare and financial protection for economically vulnerable families as important welfare priorities. But the real test of any healthcare policy lies not in announcements or registration figures, but in how effectively it reaches beneficiaries.
The government needs to answer whether HIMCARE beneficiaries are receiving timely cashless treatment, whether empanelled hospitals are providing services without unnecessary hurdles and whether grievances over treatment approvals and claims are being addressed.
Similarly, the RTI disclosures underline the need for a consolidated database of major surgical procedures, regular medical audits and public disclosure of hospital-wise health statistics.
The larger question confronting the Sukhu government is whether its healthcare administration is equipped to match its political promises with transparent, measurable outcomes.
For a state where government hospitals remain a lifeline for thousands of families, healthcare cannot be judged merely by the number of schemes launched or cards issued. Accountability must ultimately be measured by the quality, accessibility and transparency of treatment delivered to patients.


